Snape evil????

**Hermione Granger** · Posted: Sat Sep 08, 2007 7:25 pm Post subject:

lockyfan wrote:

yes I agree with the snae being a slytherin all the time.

Snape would ahve blamed himself as much as harry for lily's death, because he would have felt that had he have not told Voldemort what he had heard, Lily would have still been alive, with James, But alive.

It was only love of lily that made hgim save harry, nothing else. He hated Harry for so many reasons and mainly because he was his fathers son. He always described harry as being like "him", meaning James.

Yup that's right, but Snape's right Harry is like James and Snape has a lot of reasons to hate him

lockyfan · Posted: Thu Sep 13, 2007 6:56 am Post subject:

yeah, but the thing is, snape had apredetermined mind to hate harry, because of James. He had that hatred or potential to hate harry right away.

So really, snape could have been nicer to harry and would have had a great friend and ally, instead he made harry his enemy for so long.

**Hermione Granger** · Posted: Fri Sep 21, 2007 8:06 am Post subject:

lockyfan wrote:

yeah, but the thing is, snape had apredetermined mind to hate harry, because of James. He had that hatred or potential to hate harry right away.

So really, snape could have been nicer to harry and would have had a great friend and ally, instead he made harry his enemy for so long.

Give Snape some credit, locky... don't you think Snape found it hugely dissapointing that Lily's son, whom he was to protect out of his love for Lily, was more like James than Lily? Snape is only human,,, he wanted Harry to remind him of Lily, but instead, Harry reminded Snape of James, his arch-enemy... It's not Harry's fault that Harry is like James in many ways, but I think it would have been difficult for Snape to accept him as he is.